Set in 1986 New York, PaperTiger is a crime drama about the modest, middle class Pearl family which includes engineer Irwin (Miles Teller), his wife Linda/Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and their sons Scott (Gavin Goudey) and Ben (Roman Engel). They are living a quiet existence until they reconnect with Irwin’s estranged older brother Gary (Adam Driver), a charismatic former NYPD cop, not security consult who reconnects with the family. Gary offered Irwin the chance use his engineering background to be get involved with a clean-up that will help the family what with college coming up so on for Scott and other financial issues. However, when Irwin takes the boy to the sight one night, paranoia gets the best of the Russians and when they begin to threaten the family, Irwin goes to big brother Gary to take care of the situation.
Gotta love the Cinemark Secret Movie, otherwise I doubt I would have seen this one. There hasn’t been a ton of advertising as far as I’ve seen and this isn’t typically my type of movie so this would most likely have flown under my radar. Being a captive audience to a movie that I might no have seen otherwise can sometimes be a good thing. And in general, the success rate of these has been pretty good of late. This continues to be one of the better ones so glad I got to see it.
First up, the case. It’s pretty stacked with the three leads. Let me start off with Miles Teller—- boy have I come around on him. As he’s aged, I think he’s aged out of the douchy roles he used to get . Much like his part in Eternity which is when he turned the corner for me, the character here couldn’t be farther from the arrogant people he used to play. I didn’t even recognize him at first. He his aging VERY nicely. He was giving me Patrick Dempsey and I liked Irwin instantly. I also really dug Scarlett Johansson in this. The character I most associate her with is Natasha Romanov, the Black Widow, a SPY. As such, she should b play different roles and emotions. Unfortunately, she never got to do much of that in the MCU. I was reminded here that, oh yeah, this woman CAN act and it was really great to see her in a sympathetic role. And finally, Adam Driver. He’s always interesting to me. He is not at all what I could categorize as conventionally attractive, but it never really matters with him. He always delivers. His Gary is an absolute foil to Irwin and it all seems so natural. He just IS cooler than Irwin. He’s got a confidence and presence that his kid brother just doesn’t have. When he says he’s going to “take care of things”, you believe it. And, has confident as he always is, you still like the guy. Honorable mention to Gavin Goudey and Roman Engel. They are more plot devices than anything, but they are likable enough, annoying enough and when they are called upon to play scared, they really do.
I walked in at about 7:05. Usually there are a ton of trailers and ads but this one must have started right at 7:00 so I was a little annoyed and also felt like I was playing catch up for most of, it no all the movie. I wasn’t sure of the tone that this movie was going to have. When the hook happens, there is a prevailing sense of anxiety and dread but to the film’s credit, it manages to conserve it’s violence til the third of the movie, but leading up to that, you are constantly wondering if and when that other shoe is going to drop. All the while, they are building the characters and their dynamics which made for good storytelling.
I thought the pacing was good and the scope of the movie felt intentionally small. This isn’t earth shattering. The events really do only affect this small cast of characters. And though the story of the brothers and their involvement with the Russian mafia, Linda/Hester also has some weighty stuff going on. The boys, although minor characters, are definitely important to the plot and have some things going on with them too. The balance was nice.
The ladies around me did NOT enjoy the ending, but I dunno, it kinda worked for me. I came in feeling like I was playing catch up. By the end, I still felt a little out of the loop and it seems like that might have been intentional. Like life, things are rarely tied up in a neat little bow. And for the record, these ladies also didn’t even realize that it was Scarlett Johansson in the movie so they probably aren’t the best barometer or gauging the ending- it might have just gone over their heads.
I think it’s worth seeing. Not sure you need to run out and see it in theaters, but definitely one to catch when it’s streaming. Because of the genre, I can’t say that the rewatchability is high, but easily worth an initial watch.
My score: 8
Don’t be a Paper Tiger, let’s hear you roar in the comments. And until next time…